▲5%
$62,791
Avg. Base Salary (USD)
/ year
Avg. Base Salary (USD)
25%
$59k
MEDIAN
$63k
75%
$93k
The average salary for a Payroll Supervisor is $62,791 in 2025
Base Salary
$59k - $93k
Bonus
$0 - $2k
Total Pay
$56k - $83k
Is Average Experienced Payroll Supervisor with Payroll Administration Skills Salary in New York, New York your job title? Find out what you should be paid
Use our tool to get a personalized report on your market worth.What's this?
EXPLORE BY:
Featured Content
‹
Remote Work
New research shows how to set pay for remote employees
Gender Pay Gap
New research shows that each woman experiences the disparity of gender pay gap in different ways, depending on her position, age, race and education.
Compensation Best Practices Report
From compensation planning to variable pay to pay equity analysis, we surveyed 4,900+ organizations on how they manage compensation.
Salary Budget Survey Report
See how organizations are shifting their salary budgets this year.
Retention Report
Get strategies you can use to retain top talent and learn how impactful employee retention really is.
Variable Pay Playbook
Before you decide whether variable pay is right for your org, get a deeper understanding of the variable pay options and the cultural impact of pay choices.
›
What is the Pay by Experience Level for Payroll Supervisors?
▲32%
What Do Payroll Supervisors Do?
Find your market worth – how it works:
Common Health Benefits for a Payroll Supervisor
Medical
63%
Dental
50%
Vision
38%
None
38%
Gender Breakdown for Payroll Supervisors
Female
66.7%
Male
33.3%
This data is based on 6 survey responses. Learn more about the gender pay gap.
FAQs About Payroll Supervisors
What is the highest pay for Payroll Supervisors in New York?
Our data indicates that the highest pay for a Payroll Supervisor in New York is $NaN / year
What is the lowest pay for Payroll Supervisors in New York?
Our data indicates that the lowest pay for a Payroll Supervisor in New York is $NaN / year
How can Payroll Supervisors increase their salary?
Increasing your pay as a Payroll Supervisor is possible in different ways. Change of employer: Consider a career move to a new employer that is willing to pay higher for your skills. Level of Education: Gaining advanced degrees may allow this role to increase their income potential and qualify for promotions. Managing Experience: If you are a Payroll Supervisor that oversees more junior Payroll Supervisors, this experience can increase the likelihood to earn more.